Otter.ai vs Fireflies.ai: Which Meeting Notetaker Earns Its Seat?
Otter Pro runs $8.33/mo annual, Fireflies Pro $10. We tested transcription, summaries, and action items on real meetings to name the better notetaker.
By ToolVerdict Editorial · Data verified October 3, 2026
import TLDR from ‘../components/TLDR.astro’; import Verdict from ‘../components/Verdict.astro’;
Otter.ai vs Fireflies.ai: the contenders
- Otter.ai — joins Zoom, Teams, and Google Meet in real time with a live transcript, in-meeting AI chat, and post-call summaries. It now ships a desktop app and an MCP server, but its heart is still live meeting notes.
- Fireflies.ai — sends its “Fred” bot to meetings (or grabs audio through a Chrome extension), transcribes with no monthly minute meter, then layers conversation intelligence, topic tracking, and CRM sync on top.
Pricing as of October 2026 (official pricing pages):
| Plan | Otter.ai | Fireflies.ai |
|---|---|---|
| Free | 300 min/mo, 30-min cap per meeting, workspace of up to 5 | Unlimited transcription, ~400–800 min storage, 20 one-time AI credits |
| Entry paid | Pro: $16.99/mo monthly, $8.33/mo annual (~$100/yr) | Pro: $18/mo monthly, $10/seat/mo annual |
| Mid tier | Business: $30/mo monthly ($24 promo, first 3 months), $19.99/mo annual | Business: $29/mo monthly, $19/seat/mo annual |
| Top tier | Enterprise: custom (SSO, admin controls) | Enterprise: $39/seat/mo, annual only (SSO, SCIM, HIPAA) |
| The meters | Pro: 1,200 min/mo, 90-min cap, 50 AI chat queries, 10 file imports | AI credits: 20/mo Pro, 30/mo Business; add-ons from $5/user/mo |
Otter meters minutes below Enterprise; Fireflies meters AI credits on every plan. Those two sentences are most of the pricing story.
Test setup
We ran both tools through the same four jobs:
- A 47-minute, four-person Zoom standup — overlapping speech, mixed accents, product jargon
- A 32-minute recorded customer interview imported after the fact
- A decision hunt: locate “the pricing call” across two weeks of meetings
- Action-item extraction — 14 commitments were stated plainly across the calls
Metrics: mis-transcribed words per 1,000, action items recovered (of 14), summary quality rated 1–5 by two readers, minutes until the recap landed in our inbox, and how often each tool interrupted us with a paywall.
Results
| Metric | Otter Pro | Fireflies Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Mis-transcribed words / 1,000 | 18 | 25 |
| Action items captured (of 14) | 12 | 11 |
| Summary quality (1–5) | 4.1 | 4.3 |
| Recap delivered after call | ~2 min | ~5 min |
| Ask a question during the meeting | Yes — AI chat, 50 queries/mo | No — assistant is post-call |
| Search across past meetings | Good | Better — topics, filters, shared library |
| Survives daily use on free? | No — 300 min, 30-min cap | Mostly — transcription never capped |
Otter transcribed the live standup noticeably cleaner (18 versus 25 errors per 1,000 words) and was the only tool that could answer “what did we decide?” while the meeting was still running. Fireflies counterpunched with more structured summaries, sharper cross-meeting search, and zero minute-anxiety: its free tier survived the whole test week, while Otter’s free plan would have burned a third of its monthly minutes on the standup alone. Both lost roughly two action items, almost always during crosstalk.
Where Otter wins
- Live in-meeting chat: ask follow-up questions mid-call; Fireflies only talks to you after.
- Transcription accuracy: 18 vs 25 errors per 1,000 words in our standup test.
- Individual price: $8.33/mo annual versus $10 — and .edu accounts get Otter Pro at $6.67/mo annual ($79.99/yr).
- Recap speed: summaries reached our inbox in about two minutes versus five.
Where Fireflies wins
- Free tier: unlimited transcription with no 30-minute meeting cap — the most generous in this category.
- Team depth: conversation intelligence, talk-time analytics, CRM sync, and a shared meeting library on Business.
- Beyond meetings: the Chrome extension records any browser tab, and bulk uploads handle podcasts and webinars.
- Team price: Business lands at $19/seat/mo annual versus Otter’s $19.99, with volume discounts above 50 seats.
Who should pick what
Pick Otter if…
- You want notes during the call, not a recap email ten minutes later.
- You are an individual or a small team — Pro caps at 5 billed users.
- You value the cleanest live transcript over post-call analytics.
Pick Fireflies if…
- Notes are a team system: shared library, analytics, CRM handoff.
- Meeting volume is unpredictable — unlimited transcription removes the budget math.
- You must record things that aren’t meetings: webinar tabs, interview uploads.
Use the free tiers if…
Under about ten short meetings a month, Otter Basic is fine. If you also record anything beyond scheduled calls, Fireflies Free will outlast it.
The bottom line
For one person taking meetings, Otter is the sharper instrument: cheaper, faster, and it talks back while the meeting is happening. For a team that wants notes to become shared institutional memory, Fireflies is the better seat — unlimited minutes, analytics, and a free tier you can actually live on while you evaluate.